February 10th, 2010

Confederates in the Attic: Dispatches from the Unfinished Civil War by Tony Horwitz
My rating: 5 of 5 stars
This is one of the best books about the Civil War, or the War Between the States if we northerners are being polite, that I’ve ever read. But really, that’s because it’s not about the Civil War at all. Instead, Tony Horwitz studies the footprint left by the Civil War and how we are still facing most, if not all, of the important issues of the war. This book is not an academic study, it is more of a travel story: one man’s journey into history, beginning with his childhood fascination with the war and ending with, well, more experience but very few conclusions. But I’m okay with that, because these issues, race, heritage, and the interpretation and misinterpretation of history are not the kind of things that we never really do reach conclusions on, ever. I found this book is a satisfying read anyway, because it illuminated many points of view that I had no real understanding of before.
Raised and educated in the north I never really understood the glory of the romantic south. I remember watching Gone with the Wind with my father. He would grow soft and sigh and Scarlett’s fortitude. I turned to him and asked
“Why do people like this movie?”
“Because it reminds them of a lost time, of something they can never really get back.”
“But they were wrong, and they lost.”
The conversation died there. I clearly didn’t get it and my father did not want to push the point with his ten year old. That I was sitting through a cinematic epic that did not contain spaceships was enough of a victory. I high school we were taught about how the Confederate states were well within their right to secede, but we didn’t dwell on it. The AP was in May and we had a lot of ground to cover. I get it now Scarlett. You were one classy lady. I understand why some people want to fly the Confederate flag over state houses and why some people weep at the sight of it. This is a story told in the only way it can be told, shades of Confederate gray.
Every chapter and story is interesting and worth reading. I felt that the amount of time spent with the hardcore re-enactors lagged a bit, but it definitely wasn’t bad or boring. It just seemed like these guys were deluding themselves, searching for their “period rush”, while so many other things were going on around them in the contemporary world. Undoubtably that was one of the points.
I know that the attitudes and personalities recored here do not form a majority in the south today (especially that of arch hardcore re-enactor Robert Lee Hodges); but it does seem like they permeate southern culture. I wonder how how many of these attitudes have changed in the ten plus years since this book was published. I imagine not much.
View all my reviews >>